+- HELOVIA || The Way to the Sun (http://helovia.com)
+-- Forum: Out of Character (http://helovia.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1)
+--- Forum: Archives (http://helovia.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=11)
+---- Forum: Stealth Archives (http://helovia.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=65)
+---- Thread: Coagula No. 4 (Roland's circlet to Toulouse) (/showthread.php?tid=26781)
Coagula No. 4 (Roland's circlet to Toulouse) - Toulouse - 03-10-2017
A crown for the head full of secrets.
Split feet for the stag.
Split feet for the stag.
AB: 0/2
DT: 0/4
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Tiamat - 03-11-2017
Tiamat protects RIKYN.
A crown for the head full of secrets. — Unicorn reference and rank reference (phantom)
Split feet for the stag. — Appearance reference and companion reference (cerndyr)
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Toulouse - 03-12-2017
Toulouse gives a great sigh, twisting his lip in disappointment.
"Tiamat, you think too lowly of me"
Rikyn is NOT sought.
AB: 1/2
DT: 0/4
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Toulouse - 03-14-2017
TIME IS UP
ROLAND'S HORN CIRCLET WAS SOUGHT
ROLAND'S HORN CIRCLET WAS SOUGHT
A crown for the head full of secrets.
Split feet for the stag.
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Toulouse - 03-14-2017
OH AND NOTE: this was a personal stealth needed for a quest and not for the Edge.
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Odd - 03-14-2017
If you are in a herd, you cannot have a 'personal stealth'.
Judging to follow.
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Toulouse - 03-14-2017
Smitty asked me to note this, i was just doing as I was told.
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Charks - 03-14-2017
A crown for the head full of secrets.
Roland is a unicorn
Roland's profile states that he is secretive.
Roland is a phantom (sneak rank.)
+1 | Species ref - yup!
0 | Personality ref - already used this line for a clue!
0 | Rank ref - Already used this line for a clue!
Split feet for the stag.
Roland has cloven hooves
Roland is male (stag = male)
+1 | Appearance ref - yup!
0 | Gender ref - already used this line for a clue!
2/3 is a fail from me
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Toulouse - 03-14-2017
@charks
from the stealth rules
Each "line" is considered as separate and must stand alone in regards to being solved. Lines can either be broken by a period or entered below to the next line on a page. Multiple clues can be present in a single line.
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Blu - 03-14-2017
My verdict is the same as Charks. I've copy pasted the stealth guidelines below, because while you are correct in a manner Neverr, the issue is how you revealed the clues, by line instead of by phrase. Yes technically a line can have multiple clues because a line can have multiple phrases, and the clues are judged by phrase. If they were judged by line then you've only got two lines here so that'd auto fail. Judges are not going to assume what you consider a phrase or what you don't, so you must specify. We judge based on what you have told us.
Each "line" is considered as separate and must stand alone in regards to being solved. Lines can either be broken by a period or entered below to the next line on a page. Multiple clues can be present in a single line.
There can be multiple phrases in a line. A clue is considered a phrase as determined by the way the thief reveals their stealth. The same phrase cannot be applied for more than one clue to be counted however.
Do not provide multiple clues for the same phrase in an attempt to have it make more sense. Provide only 1 clue per phrase.
ex.
"bitch"
-- this is both a single line and a single phrase, so it cannot mean both gender, personality, and companion as clues, but only one of those things.
-- The revealer needs to provide the one clue that it is - do not list all 3 and hope judges pick the most applicable one.
"lonely excalibur boy"
-- this is a single line and 1-3 phrases depending on how it's revealed.
-- Lonely can count as one clue, but cannot be both personality and rank clues - only one clue should be provided to be judged anyway.
-- Similarly the phrase "lonely" cannot be used to signify rank, and also be used in the phrase "lonely excalibur" to mean a single-horned unicorn species clue, because lonely was already used in a phrase.
-- Excalibur without lonely can be its own phrase however to signify a species clue.
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Tamme - 03-15-2017
Per request, an alternative judgment
A crown for the head full of secrets.
Roland is a unicorn
Roland's profile states that he is secretive.
Roland is a phantom (sneak rank.)
+1 | Unicorn species/crown reference
0 | Full of secrets - I feel this is too vague because everyone has secrets!
0 | You've already used secrets as a clue for him being secretive on his profile! Each phrase has to be its own clue. If I had chosen the sneak rank to judge instead, I'd still put it at 0 because "head full of secrets" doesn't indicate his rank/position is inherently secretive!
Split feet for the stag.
Roland has cloven hooves
Roland is male (stag = male)
+1 | Split hooves for an appearance ref!
+1 | Stag - gender ref
3/3 Is a pass from me!
I'll talk to the team about a tie breaker and/or an alternative judgment.
EDIT: I'd also like to add that Roland would NOT know about this attempted stealth because the Basin did not attempt to block!
RE: Coagula No. 4 - Odd - 03-15-2017
A crown for the head full of secrets.
Roland is a unicorn
--- +1 species
Roland's profile states that he is secretive.
--- 0, to me, being secretive is not the same as necessarily having a head full of secrets. Isopia is secretive, but doesn't have secrets.
Roland is a phantom (sneak rank.)
---0 already used 'secretive' as a clue, and clues can't be used more than once!
Split feet for the stag.
Roland has cloven hooves
--- +1 Appearance
Roland is male (stag = male)
--- +1 Gender
+3 is a pass from me!
For future stealths, please reveal your stealths with the proper formatting, so that it is unambiguously clear where your clues come from in your lines. i.e., this stealth should read:
A crown
—Roland is a unicorn
for the head full of secrets.
—Roland's profile states that he is secretive.
— Roland is a sleuth
Split feet
—Roland has cloven hooves
for the stag.
—Roland is male (stag = male)
that would be my new one