CHALLENGE - POST 1
[+/- 3] Prose: Was time taken to write this, spelling, grammar, artistic use of words,flow, emotion etc.
[+/- 2] Ease of Read: Could you make sense of it the first time around
[+/- 5] Realism: Was the attack used as realistically as magic allowed. Take off points here for godmoding or overly aggressive use of power. Take off points here if the character physically attacks without the use of magic.

DEFENDER - POST 1
[+/- 3] Prose: Was time taken to write this, spelling, grammar, artistic use of words,flow, emotion etc.  
[+/- 2] Ease of Read: Could you make sense of it the first time around
[+/- 5] Realism: Was the attack used as realistically as magic allowed. Take off points here for godmoding or overly aggressive use of power. Also here would be a place to remove points if the character responded illogically to an attack. Take off points here if the character physically attacks without the use of magic.

CHALLENGER - POST 2
[+/- 3] Prose: Was time taken to write this, spelling, grammar, artistic use of words,flow, emotion etc.  
[+/- 2] Ease of Read: Could you make sense of it the first time around
[+/- 5] Realism: Was the attack used as realistically as magic allowed. Take off points here for godmoding or overly aggressive use of power. Also here would be a place to remove points if the character responded illogically to an attack. Take off points here if the character physically attacks without the use of magic.

DEFENDER - POST 2
[+/- 3] Prose: Was time taken to write this, spelling, grammar, artistic use of words,flow, emotion etc.  
[+/- 2] Ease of Read: Could you make sense of it the first time around
[+/- 5] Realism: Was the attack used as realistically as magic allowed. Take off points here for godmoding or overly aggressive use of power. Also here would be a place to remove points if the character responded illogically to an attack. Take off points here if the character physically attacks without the use of magic.

CLOSING DEFENSE
[+/- 5] Realism: Was the attack used as realistically as magic allowed. Take off points here for godmoding or overly aggressive use of power. Also here would be a place to remove points if the character responded illogically to an attack. Take off points here if the character physically attacks without the use of magic.

------------------------------------

BONUS
+1 point for mention of opponent's stature or ability, mention of a previous magic battle/encounter, mention of the time of day and settings, least damage during battle
-1 point for excessive bleeding, passing out or dying.

------------------------------------

TOTALS
CHALLENGER: 10 (add or subtract from ten)
DEFENDER: 10 (add or subtract from ten)