A gold star on your mantle
He has one ToTM star on his profile
Deceiver, you're a faker to my eyes
Gaucho has antlers, making him look like a unicorn
Thick, black smoke from your pipe
Has thick, black hair on a bay body. When you google "pipe" it comes up with dark brown, often striped wooden pipes with black finishings.
Lit even at night
Dragon's Throat flame always burns.